Home  
  MRFD Activities  
  Publications  
  Members  
  EQ Current Issue  
  EQ Previous Issue  
  Archives  
  Resource Links  
  Contact Us  
 
Previous issue
 
 
   

 

<< BACK TO CONTENTS

::: Modernity, Tradition & Contested Space :::


Armed-conflict and Women's Well-being in Manipur

By Homen Thangjam

The disturbing feature about women's response to the ongoing conflict is their perpetual engagement in fighting against conflict and the multiple roles they take up. Both features affect their well-being and disturb the contours of social capital.


INTRODUCTION

High concrete walls and tall iron gates around traditional homes symbolise Manipur's 'unwell-being'. Until a recent past, bamboo fences, hedges and bamboo wickets were barriers used against straying cattle, not against people. Every courtyard in a leikai (village/town locality) was passable from one end to the other through small openings. Erecting fences between two neighbours symbolised the existence of hostile neighbourhood or enmity. But increasing number of such enclosures now signifies barriers against people. This malaise, unknown before, is borne out of anxiety and distrust. This anxiety and distrust have their roots in the conflict that has permeated into the Manipuri society so prominently in the last four decades. The resultant outcome has its ramifications that affect various dimensions of the well-being of the people.

It is the intense nature of the conflict that has produced two inter-related social issues. One, restrictions in every dimensions of life. Two, assumptions of multiple roles by Manipuri women vis-à-vis the conflict. In order to put the issues into perspective, it is essential to analyse the production and distribution of power, wealth, and destitution during conflict. This approach is different from analysing the causal factors responsible for armed-conflict. Addressing the original sources of grievances that led to current conflict does not necessarily address the dynamics of the conflicts generated. In other words, there is a need to look at what kind of impact conflict itself has produced over a period of time.

UNDERSTANDING WELL-BEING IN MANIPUR

In traditional Manipuri society, well-being of individuals was understood in terms of collective responsibility and welfare. The existence of a form of social capital, social support systems and communitarian approaches to livelihood questions sustained well-being. In addition, the traditional concept of communal ownership of land1 and other natural resources gave a lifeline to the poor. The prevalence of the lallup system2 necessitated a communitarian approach to issues related at community level. One could find this ethos embedded either in work culture (sharing of labour known as khutlang) or during response to a crisis. The extension of this social capital operates at other levels of the society and work on the principle of mutual trust and reciprocity. Thus, Lup (community level associations or clubs) served to meet exigencies. Commenting on the significance of singlup (association that oversees the last rites), one of the many lups, R. Brown writes, 'In the event of a villager sinking into a state of extreme poverty, these clubs supply him with necessary food. In sickness, they look after him, and when dead, provide the wood etc. for his last rites. In this way, although many of the inhabitants are very poor, actual starvation or fatal neglect is rendered impossible.'3 In this way, deprivations and destitutions were contained.

WOMEN'S WELL-BEING

Historically, the state played an important role to protect the well-being of women. This is evident from the institution of Pacha loishang (women's court), the women's right to appeal4 and economic freedom accorded to them. While social justice informed the state, at the societal level social relations were governed by principles of collective endeavours, reciprocity and sharing.

Functional occupation of the males in the service of the State, the lallup system, left the trade and economic space, other manual works and professions to women. Keithel (marketplace) solely belonged to the women. Manjushree Sircar opines that women belong to a wider extra domestic world, and exert political power that arises out of their socio-economic roles.5 In addition to the lallup system, depopulation of males during the 'Seven Years Devastation'6 was responsible for women taking up trade and economic activities. Moreover, the advent of colonialism in 1891, which integrated Manipur to a wider capitalist system and improved transportation network enabled them to extend their trading activities beyond Manipur.

At the societal level, well-being of women is generated through collective activities. For example, the role of the community becomes visible once a woman becomes pregnant. A first-time would-be mother is advised or taught childbirth lessons in special lunches or dinners by friends and relatives. After a child is born, the maternal grandmother or an aunt assists the mother in taking care of the baby. Visitors bring special food items for the mother. The tradition of shared breast-feeding or sharing of motherhood ensures a better chance for survival of every child born in the community. Neighbours and leikai women help in tending and caring the child, giving relief to the mother.

Yet, there are opinions, which point out gender biases of the time in the domestic sphere. Dun writes, 'With their industry and usefulness women hold a very inferior position and are considered more in the light of goods and chattels than as persons to be treated with honour and consideration'.7 McCulloh opines, 'A man can put away his wife without any fault on her part…. Women are really slaves of their husbands.'8 Women were also victims of polygamy9 and other forms of male oppression. However, these deviances, unknown before, originated once a conservative religious ideology10 crept in and the traditional society was replaced by a colonial society. The abolition of institutions and a political system that was gender sensitive resulted in loss of women's status.

THE PRESENT SITUATION

Subsequent changes brought about by British colonialism and Manipur's integration to India has brought in new dimensions to well-being and livelihood questions. While pacha loishang and women's right to appeal have disappeared over the time, the institution of keithel and women's economic role have persisted. The abolition of lallup system (replaced by tax system) and monetisation of the economy by the British in 1892 added more burdens on women in terms of running the family. At the same time, the introduction of machines and machine made goods rendered many jobless and affected traditional domain of women's productive work.11 Amidst the rising hardship, women also continued to perform traditionally assigned gendered-roles such as domestic chores and weeding during the paddy season. Subsequent integration of Manipur with India has not altered the roles of women.

The principles of welfare-ism that India rejoiced (till the last decade of the 1980s) was juxtaposed against the image of a modern nation-state caught in a 'game of catch up'-a phrase which has come to be called as 'progress' and 'development'.12 The desired 'trickle down effect' of welfare-ism was minimal. At the same time, 'development' and 'progress' unleashed violence, which rendered many landless and destroyed their livelihoods. Shrinking opportu-nities and problems of unemployment has become an increasing trend. There are 397152 unemployed youths in the state out of which the female share is 106067.13 Women are usually in a more disadvantaged position because of their low skill (technical) and low educational attainment. There are education differentials with female literacy at 59.70 percent and male literacy at 77.87 percent as per the 2001 Census. The additional task women take up in the rising tide of unemployment is enormous. Maximum burden for sustaining the family is on women. This is evident in the keithels. Women also form the largest group of marginal workers. As per the Census of India, 1991, female marginal workers constituted 57 percent. The 2001 Census puts the urban and rural divide at 13.70 and 18.16 percentage respectively to the total main workers.

Increasing physical violence against them also worsens the problem. Susila states that between July 1998 and December 2001, there were 737 cases (domestic violence) in the Family Counseling Centre.14 They are the most vulnerable group in the emerging trend of militarisation in the state.

ARMED-CONFLICT IN MANIPUR

Conflict is a struggle between individuals or collectives over values or claims or status, power and scarce resources. The aims of conflicting parties are to assert their values or claims over those of others.15 Conflict is embedded in society and cannot be separated from ongoing political and social processes. Thus, conflict is not the irrational breakdown of societies or economies: rather it is the reorder-ing of society in particular ways. However, conflict becomes problematic when it takes the shape of an armed-conflict. Armed-conflict can be understood as a contested incompatibility, which concerns government and/or territory where the use of armed force between two parties, of which at least one is the govern-ment of a state, and results in at least 25 battle related deaths.16 Cliffe and Rock opine, 'Once violent conflict (militarized violence) emerges it transforms itself and all around it-the state, livelihoods, economy and social relations'.17 An examination of the situation of conflict in Manipur reveals this reality.

Armed-opposition movements in Manipur are grounded in ethno-nationalism and have a historical setting. There are more than 20 armed-opposition groups in the state. Their demand ranges from separate statehood to self-determination. Every group is engaged in fights against what they call 'Indian occupational forces'. The prevalence of military and armed-opposition groups and laws to combat armed-opposition movements have created a situation of internal war in the state. In addition, there are other derivatives of conflict in the form of bandhs, economic blockades, strikes, etc. that cause destruction to private and public properties, shortages of food supplies and essential commodities.

THE STATE'S RESPONSE TO ARMED-OPPOSITION MOVEMENTS

The aspiration for independence from India has been met by a renewed Indian determination to secure the territorial integrity of the Union. India's response had been the perpetual reliance on military methods and enactment of anti-people laws. This has been simultaneously played out with increased Central funding as the best way to curb insurgency. The Indian Army with support from the paramilitary forces and state police are engaged in fighting against the armed-rebels in Manipur or the Northeast. In the late 1991, the military operation involved at least four Indian Army divisions and 270 paramilitary companies.18 Military action is justified under the wide rubric of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act 1958.

Increasing security related expenditure has constricted the availability of funds to undertake development activities in the state. The state spends almost 70 paisa per rupee on administrative expenses. Of the administrative expenses, policing consumes up to 70 percent of the total.19 The Ministry of Home Affairs has taken up a 100 percent centrally funded special scheme for modernisation of police forces in the Northeast. In addition, the Centre would supply arms and ammunition, vehicles, communication equipment and other essential equipment. Under this plan, the Centre agreed to reimburse all counter insur-gency expenses incurred by the Northeast states in the last 20 years but asked the state governments to intensify its operation against the insurgents. An amount of Rs. 377 crores, approximately, was released during the periods 1997-98, 1998-99 and 1999-2000.20 Chief Minister of Manipur had earlier urged the Centre to release Rs. 1040 millions as reimbursement for counter-insurgency operation.21 The amount spent by the government in counter-insurgency operations in the past two decades was roughly equal to the Plan allocation for the state for the year 1998-99 which stood at Rs. 4250 millions.22 On the other hand, Manipur's annual expenditure incurred on social sector programmes fell by 21.1 percent to about Rs. 398 crores during the year 2000-01.23

The Tenth Finance Commission earmarked grants totaling Rs.144.30 crores for the Northeastern states.24 For Manipur, the amount stands at Rs. 1436.96 lakhs. This amount does not include allocation for defence forces (army and paramilitary forces) operating in Manipur. Thus, the cost of counter insurgency exercises has cut a deep dent in the developmental works of the state.

CONFLICT, RESTRICTIONS & WOMEN

In the prevailing climate of conflict, there is practically no guarantee to life. During 1992-2001, 3006 persons died in insurgent related killings in Manipur. From 2002 to May 2005, the number stood at 729.25 In addition, there are the interrelated problems of human rights violations. Women withstand the worst of conflict directly in terms of threat to life, sexual harassments, rape and restrictions upon livelihood means. They also undergo trauma when near and dear ones are arrested arbitrarily, tortured, detained or killed by any parties to the conflict. The most worrying aspect is the fear of the unknown as a woman puts it. 'Any time, any one of your relatives or even yourself, or, your own house or locality, can be a target. We cannot sleep until all the family members return safely to the house'.26 Therefore, the issue of well-being is central to their problems in a situation of conflict.

The situation of conflict creates a sense of insecurity and uncertainty. Restriction is the most disturbing outcome. Our understanding of the term encompasses the complex network of human realities imaginable in a situation of conflict, starting from circumscription on one's physical mobility to threats posed to life. Restrictions affect physical mobility and hence, restrict one's livelihood means and economic activities. The hardest hit sections are from the peasant and the working class. The cases of the keithel phambis (women vendors) and women traders highlight this reality. Enhanced exploitation and deprivations by the stronger and richer are the ultimate outcomes.

Restrictions on physical mobility hinder one's access to resources and institutions around them. Militarisation of the civil space and military occupation of places denies one's access to resources around them. Curfews, bandhs, blockades etc. disable one's access to institutions of public goods and services. Indefinite closure of educational institutions, health centres and other such institutions affect one's personal growth, development, and health.

Women's mobility in terms of conducting trade and other economic activities in the traditional past presupposed a safe environment free of restrictions and violence. One visible impact of the ongoing conflict is on the institution of keithel. These institutions are the mainstay of earning a livelihood for women and for supporting their families. The Ima keithel alone hosts more than 7000 keithel phambis on a daily basis. As a site for launching any form of protest, agitation or movement by women, keithels are affected in many ways. Boycott of keithel is one of the strategies followed by the women. At the same time, the government follows wanton imposition of keithel bandhs whenever women undertake agitations. Curfews, general strikes, and shoot-out in the market places are other incidents, which affect the keithels.

Restriction on mobility affects women traders, too. 'In this society, women are more resilient, hardworking and much more realistic than men in coming to terms with their lives. You'll find most women willing to work for long hours just to earn Rs 5. They would not mind working for eight hours, or walking 3 km. carrying the vegetables on their heads, rather than sell themselves in the flesh trade'.27 Constant frisking by the security forces hinders one's journey and causes loss of precious time.

Women had expressed their frustration against the frequent call of bandhs, general strikes and economic blockades in 2005 during the Meitei script movement in the state.28 In a symbolic gesture, a large number of women placed their kitchen utensils on the road, inviting the vehicles to run over them. They stated that the frequent impositions of bandhs and blockades have dealt a hard blow on their economy, especially in meeting the daily requirements, such as food.

Economic restrictions have created a situation of enhanced exploitation in the state. Power flows from the barrels of the guns and likewise is distributed. Women condemn payment of double taxes, extortion on the highways, confiscation of goods and money by the conflicting parties29 as ultimately those affect them. Common people become victims of those who 'can' afford to buy 'peace' from both the conflicting parties. This category of people engages in business by paying taxes to the armed rebels and state forces. They recover the same through proportional increase in prices of the commodities/services. By this logic, the rich gets richer in a situation of conflict, and the poor gets poorer.

COLLECTIVE RESPONSE & MULTIPLE ROLES

Meira Paibis or the women 'torch bearers' is a phenomenon of collective response to the excesses of the armed-forces. They draw their strength and resilience from history and the tradition of collective action.30 Meira Paibis patrol the neighbourhood late into the night with torches in their hands. Their presence is found in every village and locality in the valley area. Membership is voluntary and married women in the age group of 18 years to 80 years are the usual members. They are engaged in fighting against State repressions and human rights issues. They also persuade the armed rebels to refrain from attacking state security forces and to stop fratricide.

The disturbing feature about women's response to the ongoing conflict is their perpetual engagement in fighting against conflict and the multiple roles they take up. Both features affect their well-being and disturb the contours of social capital.

The emergence of the institution of Meira Paibis has made participation mandatory for every woman in the valley. The investment of women's energy into economically non-productive activities, in addition to earning a livelihood, is a direct outcome of conflict. During daytime, she is someone engaged in some form of productive work, even if the work is marginal. By nighttime, she has to take up the social responsibility of keeping vigil over her leikai as a Meira Paibi for which she is not paid. In between these two sojourns, she has to perform the domestic chores. Thus, health, nutrition, rest and child-care of these women are invariably affected.

On an average, a common Meira paibi spends three to four hours daily with her group in keeping vigil over the leikai. All the while they are exposed to dangers-to the bullets of the conflicting parties, sexual and physical harassment as well as to the elements of weather. Once they return home, they have to be alert to hear the clanging of the 'poles',31 and rush out to face the unknown. Then, there are times when they have to participate in dharna, procession and rally etc. stretching into days. The protest against the imposition of the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act in 1980 lasted from April 17 to May 28. The recent agitation against the removal of the same Act following the alleged rape and killing of Th. Manorama in July 2004 lasted for more than two months. If one adds, their working hour which usually begins at the wee hour of the morning (except for office goers) and lasts till late evening,32 and then the hours spent on domestic work, we get the picture of a person deprived of leisure, rest and sleep. These are important requirements for leading a healthy life. And health is one of the dimensions of well-being. Lack of health infrastructures further worsens the situation.33

Motherly roles of women are 'nurturing' and 'caring'. The situation of conflict and women's engagement in Meira Paibi movement have affected these important responsibilities. The welfare of the children, their performance in schools and socialisation are spheres in which mothers play important roles. The increasing numbers of school dropouts, tendency to join the armed-opposition groups among teenagers have taken away a mother's time from the family.

CONCLUSION

The perpetual engagement of the women collectively as peacekeepers or as protectors of civil liberty is a case of misplaced social capital. Though social investment is good for developing social capital, in a situation of conflict this associational life is not about creation or maintenance of democracy. Rather collective effort is directed at containing conflict and saving human lives. The simple fact is that militarisation has replaced democratisation in the state.

In this prevailing atmosphere, women's efforts have been to enable an individual walk freely in the street and reduce militarised violence. Whereas, in the traditional past, when it was not informed by ideas of modern democracy, associational life was not about making the street safe but was about warding off servitude and building an egalitarian lifestyle. The potentially negative impact that the collective endeavours bear on the individual well-being, in terms of livelihood questions, health consequences and family life, calls for an urgent need to end armed-conflict in the state. In the situation of conflict, two Hobbesian predicaments have emerged-preservation of life and deprivations by the stronger. The entrenched situation carries the potential for initiating further rounds of conflict in Manipur. Military measures are not the only means to tackle conflict in the state. The over emphasis on militarism by the Indian state has led Bimol Akoijam and Th. Tarunkumar to call the situation as similar to declaration of 'Disguised War'.34 To stop further alienation of the people or to end their sufferings, a multi-pronged policy should be devised. One way is to engage the warring groups in peace talks. This calls for a government with will, which can provide a platform for all to participate. Conflict resolution should not only be about preventing violence but also about supporting institutions that nurture well-being of the individuals. The Meira paibis can be a useful resource in this direction. Acknowledging the suffering of women in Manipur, it is imperative that peace be restored in the state for the larger interest of Indian democracy.

NOTES & REFERENCES

1 Legally the landholding belongs to the owners. But during non-agricultural seasons everybody has access to these lands viz. for grazing, fodder, collecting herbs etc.

2 Compulsory labour and military services were demanded for ten days in a month. In return, lands were given from which tax was appropriated in kind. When husband died, half the land was withdrawn until a male issue started contributing state services.

3 R. Brown, Statistical Account of the Native State of Manipur and the Hill Territory under its Rule, (Calcutta: Office of the Superintendent of Government Printing), 1873, p. 92.

4 Run by women, Pacha loishang looked after cases related to women. Women could appeal against injustices & were heard by the authority. By virtue of this right even capital punishments were pardoned by the kings. See B. Kulachandra Singh, 'The High Status that the Law of Manipur Accorded to Meitei Women', Manipuri text, Macha Leima, No. 15, December 2001, p. 5.

5 Manjushri Chaki-Sirkar, Feminism in a Traditional Society, (New Delhi: Vikas Publications), 1984, p. 8.

6 The period between 1819-26 is known as Chahi Taret Khuntakpa in the history of Manipur. During this period, there was continuous war between the then kingdom of Manipur and Burma (present Myanmar).

7 Capt. E.W. Dun, Gazetteer of Manipur, (Delhi: Manas Publication), (first published in 1886) 1992, p. 23.

8 W. McCulloch, An Account of the Valley of Manipur, (New Delhi: Gian Publishing House), (first published in 1859) 1980, p. 19.

9 Manjushri Chaki-Sirkar, op. cit., p. 8. Chahi Taret Khuntakpa, which led to the depopulation of male in Manipur was responsible for the practice of polygamy.

10 Ibid., p. 47. Acceptance of Hinduism as state religion and Hindu ideology in the beginning of 18th century led to emergence of patriarchal social system, which eroded women's status. A wave of conservatism crept in the society. Yet, women at all stages of their career were allowed the fullest liberty.

11 The number of women depending on traditional industries of rice pounding, flour grinding etc. had suddenly declined from 1171 in 1921 to 249 in 1931. This was because of installation of rice mills. See Lokendra Singh, Unquiet Valley, (New Delhi: Mittal Publications), 1998, pp. 138-39.

12 Rubina Saigol, 'Introduction' in Neelam Hussain, Samiya Mumtaz & Rubina Saigol (eds.), Engendering the Nation-State, Vol. 1, (Lahore: Asimorgh Publication), 1997, pp. 3-4.

13 'Live Resister of Employment Exchange as on 31-12-2000', Tenth Plan Outlay, Manipur, 2005.

14 Susila Sukham, 'Pattern of Violence against Women in Manipur', Manipuri text, The Sangai Express, September 1, 2003.

15 Jonathan Goodhand, 'Violent Conflict, Poverty and Chronic Poverty', CPRC Working Paper 6, (United Kingdom: Chronic Poverty Research Centre), 2001, p. 7.

16 Peter Wallensteen and Margareta Sollenberg, 'Armed Conflict, 1989-98', Journal of Peace Research, Vol. 36, No. 5, 1999, p. 605.

17 L. Cliffe & J. Rock, 'Identity Livelihoods and Post Conflict Recovery in Ethiopia and Eritrea', in B. Frederickson & F. Wilson (eds.), Livelihood, Identity and Instability, (Copenhagen: Centre for Development Research), 1997, p. 311.

18 Raju G.C. Thomas, 'Secessionist Movements in South Asia', Survival, Vol. 36, No. 2, Summer 1994, pp. 12-22.

19 Suresh Kr. Pramar, 'Rumbling on the Northeast States: Insurgency, Parallel Governments and Wielding Powers', Asian Tribune, July 26, 2004. http://www.asiantribune.com/show_news.php?id=10541.

20 Ministry of Home Affairs, 'Annual Report 2004: Chapter 1-North-East'. http://mha.nic.in/ch1.html#North-East

21 'Utmost Expenses Against Insurgency in the Region', Revolutionary People's Front Newsletter, Vol. 1, Issue 6, October 1998, p. 2.

22 Ibid. p. 2.

23 Bharat Thiyam, 'Poverty in Manipur', The Sangai Express, Tuesday, October 1, 2002.

24 South Asia Terrorist Portal, 2005, http://www.satp.org/satporgtp/countries/india/states/manipur/data_sheets/index.html

25 Ibid.

26 Association for Development Action & Research, Situation of Women in Manipur: 2002, (Imphal: Unpublished), p. 2.

27 Rasheeda Bhagat, 'Unemployment: Bane of Manipuri Women', Business Line, August 7, 2002.

28 The Sangai Express, Imphal, April 11, 2005.

29 Suresh Kr. Pramar, op. cit., 'In Nagaland and Manipur government servants have to pay a uniform 25 percent of their salaries to the underground. Senior officers, especially IAS officers and heads of Department are expected to pay not only the 25 percent but also ensure the regular diversion of public funds into the coffers of the underground. All over the Region, the militants levy road tax on all trucks and commercial vehicles, which sometimes adds up to almost 25 percent of the cost of the goods being transported.'

30 Historically, Manipuri women have fought two wars against the British. The First Nupi Lan (Women's agitation) 1904, was against imposition of forced labour upon the male population. The Second Nupi Lan, 1939, was against imperial hegemony/monopoly/exploitation, irregularities and malpractice in the administration of the state. In the post independence period, women played active roles in the public arena and displayed high political consciousness. In 1954 and 1959, women took active part in the demand for a responsible government in Manipur. See Ksh. Bimola Devi, 'Manipuri Women: A Study', in Naorem Sanajaoba (ed.), Manipur: Past and Present, Vol.1, (Delhi: K.M. Mittal Publications), 1988. Meira Paibi evolved from Nisha Bandi (Stop Alchohol & Drugs) movement in the 1980s. See, Bhabananda Takhellambum, Women's Uprising in Manipur: A Legacy Continued, (New Delhi: WISCOMP Foundation for Universal Responsibility), 2003.

31 A Meira Paibi usually clangs the metal telephone or electric poles with a stone or a stick and sends alarm bells signaling emergency situations.

32 We can get a comparative picture of energy spent by women on agricultural and household work from the following examples. In the Indian Himalayas, on a one-hectare farm, a pair of bullocks works 1,064 hours, a man 1,212 hours and a woman 3,485 hours in a year. In Andhra Pradesh, during the agricultural season a woman agricultural labourer works for 15 hours, from 4 am to 8 pm, with an hour's rest in between. Women contribute 53 percent of the total human hours per household. See Maria Mies, Patriarchy and Accumulation on a World Scale: Women in the International Division of Labour, (London & New Jersey: Zed Books ltd.), 1986.

33 For example, hospital beds available per 1000 persons (all areas) in 1991 is 0.79. Percentage of houses with access to safe drinking water in1991 is 39. Percentage of houses with access to toilet facilities in 1997 is 12. See, National Council of Applied Economic Research, East India Human Development Report, (New Delhi: Oxford University Press), 2005.

34 A. Bimol Akoijam & Th. Tarunkumar, 'Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act 1958: Disguised War & its Subversions', Eastern Quarterly, Vol. 3, No. I, April-June 2005, pp. 5-20.

<< BACK TO CONTENTS

 
www.manipurresearchforum.org ©2005 Manipur Research Forum, Delhi